Field Marshal Montgomery’s battle plan for Normandy, following the D-day landings on June 6, 1944, resulted in one of the most controversial campaigns of the Second World War. Carlo D’Este’s acclaimed book gives the fullest possible account of the conception and execution of Montgomery’s plan, with all its problems and complexities.
General Montgomery, despite his considerable qualities as a highly professional soldier and first-class trainer of troops, suffered from a breathtaking conceit which almost certainly stemmed from some sort of inferiority complex.
Carlo D’Este’s “Decision in Normandy” is a comprehensive and meticulously researched account of the Normandy campaign during World War II. The book provides a detailed analysis of the military strategy, leadership, and logistics involved in the invasion, and is a must-read for anyone interested in the subject.
One of the strengths of D’Este’s work is his ability to weave together multiple perspectives and sources to create a cohesive and engaging narrative. He draws on a wide range of primary and secondary sources, including personal accounts from soldiers, memoirs of military leaders, and official records, to provide a well-rounded view of the events leading up to and following the invasion.
D’Este’s attention to detail is evident throughout the book, as he meticulously examines the decisions made by both Allied and Axis commanders, and the impact they had on the outcome of the campaign. He is critical of some of the choices made by General Bernard Montgomery, in particular, arguing that his narrow focus on capturing the port of Caen led to missed opportunities and unnecessary casualties.
At the same time, D’Este is also fair in his assessment of Bernard Montgomery’s leadership, acknowledging his strengths as a strategist and his ability to inspire his troops. He similarly offers a nuanced view of other key figures, such as General Dwight D. Eisenhower and Field Marshal Erwin Rommel, highlighting both their successes and failures.
One area where the book could have been improved is in its discussion of the experiences of the soldiers on the ground. While D’Este does include some personal accounts, they are often brief and lack the emotional impact of other works on the subject. A more in-depth exploration of the human side of the war would have added depth and richness to the narrative.
Overall, however, “Decision in Normandy” is an impressive work of military history. D’Este’s thorough research and clear writing style make for a compelling and informative read. While it may not be the most accessible book for those new to the subject, it is an essential addition to any library on World War II.
Other books by this author on Goodreads
- Warlord: A Life of Winston Churchill at War, 1874-1945
- Bitter Victory: The Battle for Sicily July-August 1943
- Fatal Decision: Anzio and the Battle for Rome
- World War II in the Mediterranean, 1942-1945