Stonewall Jackson

One of the most successful Civil War books in history, Robertson’s insightful examination of the life of Thomas “Stonewall” Jackson has touched the hearts and minds of readers on both sides of the Mason-Dixon line.

You must not suppose that I would like you to profess religion without possessing it. A hypocrite is in my opinion one of the most detestable of beings. my opinion is, that every one should honestly and carefully investigate the Bible; and if he can believe it to be the word of God, to follow its teachings.

Stonewall Jackson:The Man, The Solider, The Legend by James I. Robertson Jr. is a comprehensive biography that examines the life and military career of Confederate General Thomas “Stonewall” Jackson, one of the most compelling figures of the Civil War. While Robertson’s book is highly regarded for its extensive research, it falls short in providing a nuanced and balanced portrayal of its subject.

One of the book’s strengths is Robertson’s detailed account of Jackson’s military campaigns. The author meticulously analyzes Jackson’s strategies and tactics, providing valuable insights into his effectiveness as a commander. Robertson’s extensive use of primary sources, including letters and official reports, adds credibility to the narrative and gives readers a clear understanding of the events surrounding Jackson’s military career.

However, the biography’s main weakness lies in its lack of critical analysis and balanced perspective. Robertson’s admiration for Jackson is apparent throughout the book, resulting in a somewhat hagiographic portrayal. The author tends to downplay or ignore the controversies surrounding Jackson, such as his harsh treatment of soldiers and civilians, and his problematic views on slavery. This one-sided approach limits the reader’s ability to fully grasp the complexities and contradictions of Jackson’s character.

Furthermore, the book’s writing style can be dry and overly focused on military details, making it less engaging for general readers. While it caters well to Civil War enthusiasts and military history buffs, it may not appeal to those seeking a more accessible and well-rounded biography.

In summary, Stonewall Jackson:The Man, The Solider, The Legend by James I. Robertson Jr. offers a detailed examination of Jackson’s military career, but it suffers from a lack of critical analysis and an imbalanced portrayal of its subject. While the book serves as a valuable resource for those interested in the Civil War, it may not be the most engaging or comprehensive biography for a wider audience.